UPDATE:
In this original posting I talked about common solutions to Pin Holes. My apologies for not picking up on this, but in his question Marv B. stated that prior to welding he “tried cleaning them [the components] with Brake Cleaner”. Welding and Brake Cleaners can be a deadly combination.
There are many warnings on the “everyday” chemicals we use. Often, I will simply assume that if it’s sold over the counter surely it must be safe. But the SDS (Safety Data Sheet) for a can of brake cleaner may read, “Do not use this product near open flames, welding operations or excessive heat. Vapors may decompose to harmful or fatal corrosive gasses such as hydrogen chloride and possibly phosgene.” This can be debilitating or even deadly to the Welder or those around him/her.
There are many manufacturers of cleaners, removers and degreasers used throughout our industry. Most are safe when used as directed, so pay attention to the product labeling and review the products Safety Data Sheet (SDS). Please use caution when determining how your weldment will be cleaned. Only use approved cleaners to the manufacturer’s instruction. Read the warnings and review the products SDS. As my old boss used to say, “Somebody wants you home tonight.”
Thanks to Steve 'Brewdude' Garn who shares his experience on welding and brake cleaners at (http://www.brewracingframes.com/safety-alert-brake-cleaner--phosgene-gas.html). I also want to give a special Thanks to the loyal readers that pointed my over-site. You come to us for good advice and I should pay attention to details when giving it.
PWC
**************************************
Hi Paul,
I was doing a search over the internet and came across your contact information. If you don’t mind, can you help me with a problem?
I am machining a Bearing Housing made out of 1045. I have to plug and weld some cross holes. I am using 1018 for the plugs. I am also using a tig welder to eliminate too large of a weld. My problem is that I am getting pin holes in my weld. Is it because I am not preheating the part. or is it because I am welding 1018 to 1045?
We didn’t machine the parts dry so maybe there is a light film of coolant on the parts but I tried cleaning them and that didn’t seem to help.
If you could reply back that would be great or go ahead and give me a call.
Thanks!!!
Marv B.
Hey Marv,
The welding of the materials shouldn’t be a problem.
Let me ask, the machined port looks to be made up of 3 different drilling operations. Are all 3 completed before the plug is welded in?
The reason I ask…
If the port to be plugged is drilled first (others drilled after welding) trying to weld a plug in the hole creates a condition I’ve dealt with most of my career. When trying to seal weld the only opening in any cavity the air (or gases) in that cavity heat and expand. During that expansion a pin-hole will form at some location in the weld (just on solidification) to allow that expanding gas to escape. Molten metal makes a poor seal
Pipe-Welders see this same condition when finishing the root pass in a purged pipe. If they don’t build an alternative location for the gas to escape the gas will blow through the final weld crater.
I also dealt with this condition on Flare Bevel Groove welds on a robotic application of a manufacturer where I served as Weld Engineer. We were able to remedy that with a punched whole on the faying surface of the joint.
Not sure if this is your condition, but if you’re trying to seal the only opening, it sure could be.
Let me know.
PWC
Just my opinion, nothing more. I'm a CWI who teaches Welding and Inspection. Folks ask me questions through the AWS-CWI Seminars I teach. I do my best to give them an answer that educates.
Welder Training info & All my Welding 101 Articles can be found here:
Monday, July 28, 2014
Wednesday, July 16, 2014
Weld Inspection After Coating
Hi Paul,
I see your references on The Fabricator.com website and am wondering; how I can inspect/verify welds on painted product without being destructive?
Best regards,
Eric D.
Hey Eric,
On fabricated products coatings come in many types. galvanizing, paint, even the oxidizing of a weathering steel will have negative effects on the inspection of welded products. For visual inspection (a form of nondestructive evaluation) any coating on the finished weld has the potential to mask or cover rejectable discontinuities such as size, cracks, undercut, overlap, porosity, etc… Keep in mind, when we list defects by criticality, those that come to the surface generally top the list. So there is risk in completing a visual inspection on any coated product.
That being said, as a CWI I’m often asked to do visual inspection on coated product. I do, but I will ALWAYS note that the weldment viewed was coated and that coating limited the inspection.
As for other forms of NDE…
• Die penetrant (PT) would not be affective. With die penetrants the discontinuity needs to come to the surface and the penetrent needs to enter the discontinuity through capillary action. Any coatings would not allow that to happen.
• Magnetic particle testing (MT) does have the potential to reveal sub-surface discontinuities but that ability is limited and any coating will certainly affect its dependability. MT will not work on your aluminum products, the material tested needs to be ferromagnetic.
• It’s not uncommon to do Ultrasonic testing (UT) on coated weldments. I’ve performed UT on thousands of galvanized and painted products successfully. Calibrations need to be adapted to allow for loss due to the coating, but those types of inspections are performed every day (at least in my world).
• Radiograph (RT) is another nondestructive method that would not be affected by most coatings. In fact, RT would probably be the least affected.
So there ya’ go. There are several nondestructive methods of NDE that can be performed on coated products, there are simply some adjustments that may be required due to the coating. But your most affective form of nondestructive testing is visual inspection performed before, during and after welding and prior to any coating.
Ask me the time and I build you a watch.
PWC
I see your references on The Fabricator.com website and am wondering; how I can inspect/verify welds on painted product without being destructive?
Best regards,
Eric D.
Hey Eric,
On fabricated products coatings come in many types. galvanizing, paint, even the oxidizing of a weathering steel will have negative effects on the inspection of welded products. For visual inspection (a form of nondestructive evaluation) any coating on the finished weld has the potential to mask or cover rejectable discontinuities such as size, cracks, undercut, overlap, porosity, etc… Keep in mind, when we list defects by criticality, those that come to the surface generally top the list. So there is risk in completing a visual inspection on any coated product.
That being said, as a CWI I’m often asked to do visual inspection on coated product. I do, but I will ALWAYS note that the weldment viewed was coated and that coating limited the inspection.
As for other forms of NDE…
• Die penetrant (PT) would not be affective. With die penetrants the discontinuity needs to come to the surface and the penetrent needs to enter the discontinuity through capillary action. Any coatings would not allow that to happen.
• Magnetic particle testing (MT) does have the potential to reveal sub-surface discontinuities but that ability is limited and any coating will certainly affect its dependability. MT will not work on your aluminum products, the material tested needs to be ferromagnetic.
• It’s not uncommon to do Ultrasonic testing (UT) on coated weldments. I’ve performed UT on thousands of galvanized and painted products successfully. Calibrations need to be adapted to allow for loss due to the coating, but those types of inspections are performed every day (at least in my world).
• Radiograph (RT) is another nondestructive method that would not be affected by most coatings. In fact, RT would probably be the least affected.
So there ya’ go. There are several nondestructive methods of NDE that can be performed on coated products, there are simply some adjustments that may be required due to the coating. But your most affective form of nondestructive testing is visual inspection performed before, during and after welding and prior to any coating.
Ask me the time and I build you a watch.
PWC
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)