I know what you're thinking, another early Saturday morning question.
I've been looking at the requirements of obtaining a CWB inspector certification. Am I seeing this correctly? A CWB inspector can apply for a CWI by reciprocity by nothing more than an application and fees. But a CWI who wants to be a CWB, in this case a level 2, would fill out the application, pay fees, and still have to take an exam?
Doesn't strike me as "equivalent" or fair.
Tim C. CWI, CWE
Level II VT, PT, MT, UTT
Your assessment is correct. For a CWB to apply for a CWI it’s just a fee and some paperwork. For a CWI to apply for a CWB it’s a test. Those Canucks take their welding seriously.
I was the Quality Manager in a pole manufacturing company that was CWB Certified. Every 6 months I had to hire a CWB engineer to audit my organization (and it was an in-depth look at our welding). There were a lot of hoops to jump through, but if we wanted to sell power-line poles in Canada it was a requirement.
Some of the things I liked about working in a CWB shop: 1.) Welders had to retake their Welder Qualification Tests every 2 years. I believe that helped maintain weld quality in our shop. 2.) Welder Qualifications were given using a Bevel Groove. The first pass was a Fillet Weld of a specific size up against that square edge of the Bevel Groove. The fillet had to have a restart in it. The location of the restart was marked, and 1 of the 3 required bend coupons had to contain that restart.
One of the things I didn’t like was that they consider FCAW and GMAW with a Metal-Cored wire (MCAW) the same process (for welder qualification purposes). The Welding Engineer in me (said quietly so as not to be heard across the MN/Canadian border) sees these processes as requiring different skills.
The way I turned that around was by using the CWB 2yr retesting requirement. I gave MCAW tests, had them evaluated by the CWB to Canadian standards and evaluated them myself as a CWI to AWS standards. At 6 month intervals, over a 2 year period, those Welder Qualifications were brought up to speed.
If I was an independent contract CWI I’d probably pursue the CWB route, but if you work in a shop that’s considering bringing in CWB work then CWB/CWI reciprocity is the least of your worries.